Niveles de Tolerancia a la Ambigüedad en Estudiantes Españoles de Contabilidadun Estudio Comparativo

  1. Arquero Montaño, José Luis
  2. Tejero Rioja, Concepción
Revista:
Revista de contabilidad = Spanish accounting review: [RC-SAR]

ISSN: 1138-4891

Año de publicación: 2009

Volumen: 12

Número: 1

Páginas: 95-116

Tipo: Artículo

DOI: 10.1016/S1138-4891(09)70003-2 DIALNET GOOGLE SCHOLAR lock_openDIGITUM editor

Otras publicaciones en: Revista de contabilidad = Spanish accounting review: [RC-SAR]

Resumen

La ambigüedad es la percepción de la inadecuación de la información que resulta de determinadas características de un escenario. En situaciones de toma de decisiones, la percepción de ambigüedad puede percibirse como una amenaza y supone un reto cognitivo. En esta línea la literatura ha tratado la incidencia de los niveles de tolerancia a la ambigüedad (AT) en la toma de decisiones en contextos empresariales y financieros. Este trabajo trata de estudiar los niveles de AT en una muestra de estudiantes de contabilidad comparándolos con los niveles de otros estudiantes de otras carreras de ciencias sociales. El instrumento usado es la versión española del MSTAT-II (McLain, 2008) y la muestra está compuesta por estudiantes de distintas carreras de ciencias sociales de la Universidad de Huelva. Los resultados indican un alto nivel de consistencia interna del instrumento con esta muestra. Los estudiantes de contabilidad presentan niveles de tolerancia a la ambigüedad más bajos que el resto de sus compañeros en otras carreras. Por último, se debaten las implicaciones educativas para las universidades de estos resultados.

Referencias bibliográficas

  • Accounting Education Change Commission. (AECC) Objectives of Education for Accountants: Position Statement No. 1 Issues in Accounting Education 5 1990 307 312
  • American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (2009). Mapping of the Core Competency Framework to the Skills Tested on the CPA Exam. Available online at http://ceae.aicpa.org/Resources/Education+and+Curriculum+Development.
  • J.H. Amernic, and T. Beechy Accounting students' performance and cognitive complexity: some empirical evidence The Accounting Review 59 April 1984 300 313
  • J. Amernic, N. Aranya, and J. Polluck Is there a generally accepted standard accountant? CA Magazine October 1979 34 42
  • J.L. Arquero Montaño Capacidades no técnicas en el perfil profesional en contabilidad: las opiniones de docentes y profesionales Revista Española de Financiación y Contabilidad XXIX 103 2000 149 172
  • J.L. Arquero, J.A. Donoso, S.M. Jiménez, and J.M. González Análisis exploratorio del perfil demandado para administración y dirección de empresas: implicaciones para el área contable. (Exploratory analysis of the educational profile for BA: implications for accounting) Revista de Contabilidad - Spanish Accounting Review 12 2009 (pend)
  • Arthur Andersen & Co., (1989). Perspectives on Education: Capabilities for Success in the Accounting Profession. New York.
  • K.C. Banning The Effect of the Case Method on Tolerance for Ambiguity Journal of Management Education 27 5 2003 556 567
  • A.J. Benjamin, R.E. Riggio, and B.T. Mayes Reliability and Factor Structure of Budner's Tolerance for Ambiguity Scale Journal of Social Behavior and Personality 11 1996 625 632 No. 3.
  • L.I. Bhushan, and S.B. Amal A situational test of intolerance of ambiguity Psychologia 29 1986 254 261
  • J. Budner Tolerance of ambiguity as a personality variable Journal of Personality 30 1962 29 40
  • Common Content Project (2006). The skills framework. Available online at: www.commoncontent.com.
  • L.A. Deppe, E.O. Sonderegger, J.D. Stice, D.C. Clark, and G.F. Streugling Emerging competencies for the practice of accountancy Journal of Accounting Education 9 1991 257 290 Fall
  • J.D. Dermer Cognitive Characteristics and the Perceived Importance of Information The Accounting Review 48 1973 511 519 No 3
  • V.M. DeRoma, K.M. Martin, and M.L. Kessler The relationship between tolerance for ambiguity and need for course structure Journal of Instructional Psychology 30 June 2003 104 109
  • K.S. Ebeling, and P. Spear Preference and performance on two tasks of varying ambiguity as a function of ambiguity tolerance Australian Journal of Psychology 32 2 August 1980 127 133
  • Z.E. Elias An Examination of Nontraditional Accounting Students' Communication Apprehension and Ambiguity Tolerance Journal of Education for Business 75 1 1999 38 41
  • D. Ellsberg Risk, ambiguity, and the Savage axioms Quarterly Journal of Economics 75 (November) 1961 643 669
  • E. Frenkel-Brunswik Tolerance of ambiguity as a personality variable American Psychologist 3 1948 268
  • E. Frenkel-Brunswik Intolerance of ambiguity as an emotional and perceptual personality variable Journal of Personality 18 1949 108 143
  • E. Frenkel-Brunswik Personality theory and perception R. Blake, G. Ramsey, Perception: An approach to personality 1951 Oxford University Press New York
  • A. Furnham A content, correlational and factor analytic study of four tolerance of ambiguity questionnaires Personality and Individual Differences 16 1994 403 410
  • A. Furnham, and T. Ribchester Tolerance of ambiguity: A review of the concept, its measurement and applications Current Psychology 14 1995 179 199
  • D. Ghosh, and M.R. Ray Risk Ambiguity, and Decision Choice: Some Additional Evidence Decision Sciences 28 1 1997 81 104
  • D. Ghosh Tolerance for Ambiguity Risk Preference, and Negotiator Effectiveness Decision Sciences 25 2 1994 263 280
  • F.A. Gul Tolerance for ambiguity, auditors' opinions and their effects on decision making Accounting and Business Research 16 1986 99 105
  • F.A. Gul, and J.S.L. Tsui Perceptions of Auditor Independence: The Moderating Role of Personality Corporate Governance: An International Review 2 4 1994 203 209
  • N. Harding, and M. Ren The importance in accounting of ambiguity tolerance at the national level Evidence from Australia and China Asian Review of Accounting 15 2007 6 24 No. 1
  • F. Hartmann The effects of tolerance for ambiguity and uncertainty on the appropriateness of accounting performance measures Abacus Vol. 41 3 2005 241 264
  • T. Hassall, J. Joyce, J.L. Arquero, and J.A. Donoso The Vocational Skills Gap For Management Accountants: The Stakeholders Perspectives Innovations in Education and Teaching International 40-1 2003 78 88
  • R. Hogarth Ambiguity in competitive decision-making: Some implications and tests P.C. Fishburn, I. Lavelle, Annals of Operations Research 19 1989 31 50
  • J.L. Holland Making vocational choices. A theory of careers 1973 Prentice Hall
  • n. Huber An Experiential Leadership Approach for Teaching Tolerance for Ambiguity Journal of Education for Business; 79 1 2003 52 55
  • International Federation of Accountants. Education Committee. (1996). IEG 9 Prequalification Education, Assessment of professional competence and experience requirements of professional accountants. N.Y., IFAC.
  • International Federation of Accountants. International Accounting Education Standards Board. (2008). IES 3 Professional Skills. In International Education Standards 1-8. N.Y., IFAC.
  • S.H. Jones, and R.A. Davidson Measuring the Problem-Solving Abilities of Accounting and Other Business Students: A Comparison and Evaluation of Three Methods Accounting Education 16 1 2007 65 79
  • T.A. Judge, C.J. Thoreson, V. Pucik, and T.M. Welbourne Managerial coping with organizational change: a dispositional perspective Journal of Applied Psychology 84 1999 107 122
  • M.J. Kirton A reanalysis of two scales of tolerance of ambiguity Journal of Personality Assessment 45 1981 405 414
  • K.-H. Kischkel A scale for the measurement of ambiguity tolerance Diagnostica 30 1984 144 154
  • B. Lamberton, J. Fedorowicz, and S.J. Roohani Tolerance for Ambiguity and IT Competency among Accountants Journal of Information Systems 19 1 2005 75 95
  • S.L. Liedtka, B.K. Church, and M.R. Ray Performance Variability Ambiguity Intolerance, and Balanced Scorecard-Based Performance Assessments Behavioral Research In Accounting 20 2 2008 73 88
  • D.J. Lowe, and P.M.J. Reckers The influence of outcome effects, decision aids usage, and intolerance of ambiguity on evaluations of professional audit judgment International Journal of Auditing 1 1 1997 43 59
  • A.P. MacDonald Revised scale for ambiguity tolerance: Reliability and validity Psychological Reports 26 1970 791 798
  • G.S. May, F.W. Windal, and J. Sylvestre The need for change in accounting education: an educator survey Journal of Accounting Education 13 1 1995 21 43
  • D.L. McLain The MSTAT-I: A new measure of an individual's tolerance for ambiguity Educational and Psychological Measurement 53 1993 183 189
  • D.L. McLain Evidence of the Properties of an Ambiguity Tolerance Measure (MSTATII) Psychological Reports Article currently under review 2008
  • R. Norton Measurement of ambiguity tolerance Journal of Personality Assessment 39 1975 607 619
  • M.T. Pich, C.H. Loch, and A. DeMeyer On uncertainty, ambiguity, and complexity in project management Management Science 48 2002 1008 1023
  • K.V. Pincus Auditor individual differences and fairness of presentation judgments Auditing: A Journal of Practice and Theory 9 1990 150 166
  • M. Poesio Semantic ambiguity and perceived ambiguity K. van Deemter, S. Peters, Semantic ambiguity and underspecification 1996 Stanford CA: CSLI 159 201
  • J. Pratt The effects of personality on a subject's information processing: a comment The Accounting Review 55 1980 501 506
  • S.T. Rydell, and E. Rosen Measurement and some correlates of need-cognition Psychological Reports 19 1966 139 165
  • W.W. Sherrill Tolerance of Ambiguity among MD/MBA Students: Implications for Management Potential The Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions 21 2001 117 122
  • M. Smith Personality issues and their impact on accounting and auditing Managerial Auditing Journal 14 9 1999 453 460
  • J. Tsui Tolerance for ambiguity, uncertainty audit qualifications and banker's perceptions Psychological reports 72 1 1993 915 919
  • W.K. Viscusi, and H. Chesson Hopes and fears: The conflicting effects of risk ambiguity Theory and Decision 47 1999 153 178
  • H.K. Walker, A.A. Armenakis, and J.B. Bernerth Factors influencing organizational change efforts. An integrative investigation of change content, context, process and individual differences Journal of organizational Change Management 20 6 2007 761 773
  • P. Wang, and P.S. Chan Top management perception of strategic information processing in a turbulent environment Leadership & Organization Development Journal 16 7 1995 33 43
  • M. Westerberg, J. Singh, and E. Hackner Does the CEO matter? An empirical study of small Swedish firms operating in turbulent environments Scandinavian Journal of Management 13 3 1997 251 270
  • R.R. Wharton, L.E. Parry, and G. Buntzman Success or bankruptcy: the relationship between personal and goal orientation and simulation performance Diana Page Sandra Morgan. Developments in Business Simulation and Experiential Learning 26 1999 Association for Business Simulation and Experiential Learning
  • M.E. Wright, and R.A. Davidson The Effect of Auditor Attestation and Tolerance for Ambiguity on Commercial Lending Decisions Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory 19 2 2000 67 81
  • G. Yurtsever Tolerance of ambiguity, information, and negotiation Psychological reports 89 1 2001 57 64
  • A. Zebda The problem of ambiguity and vagueness in accounting Behavioural Research in Accounting 3 1991 117 145
Fuente de los datos: Dialnet